Sussex-Lisbon Area Historical Society, Inc.

Search this site and our local communities. Wisconsin History Search Only

You may now join, or renew your SLAHS membership using your PayPal account, credit, or debit card.

Please use the following link to make a secure on-line payment.

About Us
Search this site
Monetary Donations

Artifact Donations

Buy A Brick Donation

Fundraiser Letter

Notable Links
Index to Wisconsin Brewery and Related Articles


Local History Index: Business Index

 Creamery Business History

Compiled and Edited by Michael R. Reilly

Last Revised 12/23/2009

Also read Champeny Creamery Explosion

New Store In Sussex
    On the 8th day of February, 1886, I shall open the store formerly kept by Edward Champeny, with a full assortment of dry goods, groceries, hats, caps, boots and shoes, hardware, crockery, glass-ware, paints, oils, etc., and a full line of goods usually kept in a general store. All will be sold at very low prices/ Come one and all, and be convinced as to prices and quality of goods. Highest market price paid for butter and eggs.
Yours, anxious to please,
A. J. Elliott
Waukesha Freeman, February 4, 1886, page 1. (Editor's note: This short advertisement shows that local grocers were buying privately made butter for resale to customers)

Editor's Note: All though the next couple of articles don't specially discuss Sussex-Lisbon creamery business, they're printed here to indicate the state of the business in 1890.

Co-Operative Dairying (Excerpt from an article based on a Waukesha Farmers' Institute meeting)

    W. B. Vankirk opened the discussion on "Co-Operative Dairying". He said that where cows are plenty in a neighborhood and near to the factory, it may be best for the farmers to haul their milk to the factory and use a centrifugal separator in getting out the cream.

    Mr. Utter gave some account of the working of the factory at Caldwell, where they make from 2 to 3 1/2 lbs. of butter, and about 7 lbs. of cheese from 100 lbs. of milk. The latter has brought the patrons an average of 85 cents per cwt. during the past year. Mr. Ward patronizes the same factory, but thinks there is not much profit in the dairy industry at present, as it is being overdone.

    Capt. E. Enos gave an account of how he has bred up his herd of Jerseys until he now makes 1 lb. of butter from 14 to 15 lbs. of milk, and he has 15 cows that make an average of 300 lbs. of butter per year, which he ships to private customers at 30c per pound. Source: Waukesha Freeman, March 6, 1890
Our New Factory
    The Waukesha cheese and butter manufacturing Co., consisting of Messrs. F. E. Allen and M. A. Sickles, is in working order and their new factory will soon be an accomplished fact.

    Mr. Sickles, the manager of the company is a first class and practicle dairy man, and he will prove a valuable acquisition to the business circles of the town. The Free wishes the new firm an abundant success. Source: Waukesha Freeman, March 27, 1890
    At the new Waukesha cheese and butter factory on Monday, the opening day, 2,000 pounds of milk were received and a steady increase is looked for.  Source: Waukesha Freeman, May 8, 1890

    There is quite a stir among the farmers of this neighborhood over the prospects of having a butter and cheese factory built near the center of the town, if the necessary number of cows can be obtained. Waukesha Freeman, January 22, 1891

   A butter and cheese factory is about to be started at North Lisbon. A. L. Greengo is the leader in the enterprise. Waukesha Freeman, January 31, 1891.

Merton - The office at the condensery is now completed, and Mr. Siefelt, the secretary, who through the winter lived in Milwaukee, will now have his headquarters here. Source: Waukesha Freeman, Thursday, May 6, 1915

Stories from the stone creamery on Champeny

On the northwest corner of Champeny Drive and Maple Avenue stands a stone building that has been called the "Cheese Factory," the "Sussex Alamo," the "Old Champeny Creamery," and "The Lisbon Co-operative Creamery."

The name Cheese Factory is completely wrong because it was a creamery that produced butter. It was built in1892 by Tiley Champeny who was a butter maker with his father, who ran Edward's Farm. After the death of his father on Sept. 7, 1891, Champeny came into a large inheritance and expecting it, he planned for a large production of butter.

Edward and William Champeny were 1840s pioneers in the Town of Lisbon who eventually owned more than 370 acres. At one time they owned the entire mile of land that fronted on the north side of Maple Avenue and went west on Main Street to Highway 164 today. During another time, they owned the entire mile of the west side of Maple Avenue from Main Street to Good Hope Road.

Not only were they successful land holders and farmers, but Edward started a four corners of Sussex general store in 1852 and ran it until 1884 when he disposed of the business to A.J. Elliott. Today, the site of this general store is the vacant lot on the northwest corner of Main and Maple. The land that William had most notably has the Sussex Pick 'n Save today.

Tiley's butter factory

Both Champenys were born in Somersetshire, England; William in 1814 and Edward in 1816. Both came to Lisbon in 1842 with Edward going back to Somersetshire in 1845 to marry Elizabeth Martin who he brought back to Lisbon in 1846. They had 10 children but five died young, three at 2 years, one at age 4 and the fifth at age 18. The five that were alive at Edward's death in 1891 were Anna, Tiley or "T.M.", Frank, Charles and Edwin. According to the late Roy Stier, each of the sons got $60,000 in inheritance, and Tiley used his to become a butter maker.

Tiley built his English/rural Gothic rubble construction lime stone factory and equipped it with two big cream separators and a butter-making churn. His first day of production on May 26, 1892, he made 60 pounds. It grew to 162 pounds in 1893. After this success, he started to branch out with factories in Menomonee Falls, Monches, Lake Five, Marcy (near Richmond School) and even in Fargo, North Dakota, where his brother, Frank, was a merchant.

However, Tiley who was formerly a member of the Temperance Prohibition Party became a Democratic Party voter and married Laura Overbaugh of the Fox River Valley, Appleton area in 1886.

There was a death from an industrial accident in the Town Line Road, Menomonee Falls plant and along with Tiley's drinking and business reverses he was out of business in 1901. The bankruptcy case was finally settled around 1934.

New owner

Around 1904, C.G. Daniels took over the creamery in Sussex, he purchased the defunct creamery for $1,000. Daniels continued using the left over stock of Chapeny butter crocks to package his product until they were gone. These mostly blue-imprinted crocks and some pink imprinted have become collector items. Some years ago, a pristine, pink 2-pound crock went for $362.50 at an auction. The Sussex-Lisbon Area Historical Society has a pink and two blue printed Champeny butter crocks.

C.G. Daniels also made ice cream at his Sussex creamery and limped along running the business buying milk from local farmers but never realized too much success. And in 1913, the plant was down again and to preserve its market for locally produced milk, a herd of Lisbon farmers combined to form the Lisbon Cooperative Creamery. They issued stock to farmers who paid in to restart the butter business. The key people in the restart were George Elliott, Walter Rankin, Westly Connell and Andrew L. Butler.

They ran into a problem as Sussex was not well-served by the railroad and the trucking of milk was starting to take off. Farmers could haul their big milk cans to the depot and a special train would quickly haul them to Milwaukee fluid milk companies. Shortly after, the railroads lost this business as milk trucks came online to offer farm pickup of milk and the butter and cheese factories of Waukesha started to disappear.

The Lisbon Cooperative Creamery was listed n the 1923 "Farm Journal Illustrated Rural Directory of Waukesha County," but it was headed for bankruptcy and would soon close down forever.

Inventor coverts factory

Around this time in 1926, there was a Chicago- and Waukesha-connected inventor named Roy P. Owen who bought the derelict plant for his large family. His intention was to convert the plant into a home. Owen is credited for his inventions of a water-facet driven small butter churn and most profitably, a malted milk powder dispenser for the Thompson Malted Milk Co.

He bought the factory and revamped it into a show place. The old butter factory that was turned into a stone castle-spacious home with great outside amenities was even featured in the Milwaukee Journal.

In the October 1933 Sussex Directory and Telephone Numbers produced by the Jannsens of Waukesha, parts of the Owens family are listed living at 225 Maple Ave. with telephone number 46R32. There are children listed as Dorothy, Mildred and Ralph with parents listed as Roy P. and wife Pearl who is listed as a teacher.

Soon afterward, there is a slip of advertising in the Milwaukee Journal that was found around 1938 in a drawer at the Sussex State Bank that advertises the sale by R.P. Owen of the remodeled butter factory for $2,500. The building now had a hot water heater, oil burner, built-in fireplace, artesian well, automatic water system, lily ponds and an outdoor clay tennis court.

The Fuchs family bought it around 1934. According to source Betty Mindemann, they lived in it until 1943 but other sources say until 1946. The Fullers moved to Sussex in 1939 and lived in a North Maple Avenue home just a few doors down from the Fuchs. The Fullers included Stanely Fuller and wife, Marie, first-born son Stanley Jr. and second-born Betty, (today Betty Mindemann), plus three more sisters and brothers.

Betty's memories of the converted factory were of a mahogany beamed lower library and the fish pond. She remembers that when she was learning to drive, she ended up with the car in the fish pond. Her brother Stanley graduated in 1945 and Betty in 1946 from the then two-year Sussex High School, which is the old Main Street School and today, Sussex Village Hall.

Meanwhile, the Fuller family lived in the butter factory home until the late 1960s when it sold for $20,000 to Donald Liesener who remodeled the single-family home into four rental units. It's estimated Liesener owned the property from 1969 to 1973. It was later sold to Diane Longseth.

The property eventually became badly neglected and the most recent owner, Thomas Pastor, hired a company to raze the building. The demo crew said it will dispose of the wood, recycle the metal and the stone walls will be crushed and repurposed into gravel. The property is zoned multi-family, Village officials said they did not know what Pastor plans to do with the property, but that he did want to have the building removed before the first of the year.


Home / About Us  / Membership / Search this site

Copyright Sussex-Lisbon Area Historical Society, Inc., , 2002 - 2016, Except as noted: All documents placed on the website remain the property of the contributors, who retain publication rights in accordance with US Copyright Laws and Regulations. In keeping with our policy of providing free information on the Internet, these documents may be used by anyone for their personal research. They may be used by non-commercial entities, when written permission is obtained from the contributor, so long as all notices and submitter information are included. These electronic pages may NOT be reproduced in any format for profit. Any other use, including copying files to other sites, requires permission from the contributors PRIOR to uploading to the other sites. The submitter has given permission to the website to store the file(s) for free access. Such permission may be revoked upon written notice to the website webmaster. Website's design, hosting, and maintenance are donated by Website Editor & Webmaster: Michael R. Reilly (Mike)